Installments Coming Due After Suit Is Filed Need Not Be Joined

A creditor suing on an installment contract that has no acceleration clause faces a timing problem. More payments may come due—and go unpaid—while the case is pending. Is the plaintiff required to amend his complaint each time an installment comes due? If the plaintiff fails to amend, will res judicata bar subsequent lawsuits aimed at collecting amounts that come due in the future under the same contract? The Virginia Court of Appeals dealt with these issues in Ferrell v. Playfly, LLC (decided June 16, 2026) and held that no amendment is necessary. Rule 1:6 will bar a second suit for installments that were already due at the time the first action was filed, the court held, but the rule will not bar a second suit for installments that come due afterward, even if they matured before the first case was tried.

Brad Ferrell signed a separation agreement with Playfly after it terminated him in April 2023. The agreement provided for $103,927.99 in severance, payable on Playfly’s twice-monthly payroll cycle through September 2023. It also provided for commissions and a prorated bonus payable by August 14, 2023. It contained no acceleration clause. Playfly made payments through July 2, 2023. Ferrell alleged that a June 30, 2023 letter from Playfly announced that it would stop paying because of unspecified breaches of his non-compete. Playfly then missed the July and August severance payments and did not pay the bonus.

On August 24, 2023, Ferrell filed a warrant in debt in general district court seeking $23,095.11 for the “June and July” payments. He never amended to add the later installments. He won at trial in February 2024, and Playfly paid the judgment. Ferrell then sued in the Charlottesville Circuit Court for the remaining severance and the bonus. Playfly argued that every installment had come due by September 2023, so Ferrell could have amended before trial and, under Code § 16.1-77, transferred the enlarged case to circuit court. The circuit court agreed and entered summary judgment, holding that Ferrell’s failure to amend was fatal to his second suit.

The Court of Appeals affirmed in part and reversed in part, holding that “the circuit court correctly held that Ferrell’s claims for unpaid installments were barred if those installments (1) had come due by August 24, 2023 (the date Ferrell filed his warrant in debt), and (2) were not included in the first lawsuit. The circuit court erred, however, in concluding that res judicata barred the claims for installments due thereafter on the theory that Ferrell should have amended his warrant in debt to include them.”

The court’s analysis began with Funny Guy, LLC v. Lecego, LLC, 293 Va. 135 (2017), which described Rule 1:6 as adopting the Restatement (Second) of Judgments’ broad transactional approach. Funny Guy had also noted, in dicta, that res judicata does not bar a claim that accrued after the first suit was filed. The court found ample support for that principle elsewhere. The United States Supreme Court recognized it in Lucky Brand Dungarees, Inc. v. Marcel Fashions Group, Inc., 590 U.S. 405 (2020), and it is the prevailing rule in the federal circuits, under which a plaintiff “may” supplement his pleading to add later-accruing claims but “is not required to do so.” The Restatement agrees that a judgment for breach of contract “does not normally preclude” a later action for performance that came due after the first action was commenced. (See Restatement (Second) of Judgments § 26 cmt. g.) The text of Rule 1:6(a) points the same way: it defines the preclusive “claim for relief” as the claim “set forth in” the party’s pleading.

Virginia precedent has drawn the line in the same place. In Jones v. Morris Plan Bank, 168 Va. 284 (1937), the Supreme Court of Virginia explained that an installment contract is divisible, so each default may support its own action, but each action “should include every installment due at the time it is commenced.” The Court of Appeals had applied that rule earlier this year in Seaview Apartments, LLC v. City of Newport News, 86 Va. App. 583 (2026). There, a suit over certain unpaid utility bills barred a second suit for other bills that were ripe when the first suit was filed, but not for bills that came due later. Applying these principles, the court held that Ferrell could not recover any installment that was due on August 24, 2023, but omitted from his warrant in debt. Installments that came due after that date remained recoverable. The case was remanded to the circuit court for it to determine which payments had accrued by the filing date.

The court rejected Ferrell’s argument that the then-$25,000 jurisdictional limit of the general district court excused him from joining the installments already due. He could have sued for all of them in circuit court, and Code § 16.1-77(1) would have required transfer had he amended to seek more. Quoting the Restatement, the court explained that a plaintiff who “voluntarily” sues in a court that “can grant him only limited relief, cannot insist upon maintaining another action on the claim.” (See Restatement (Second) of Judgments § 24 cmt. g.) The General Assembly has since raised the limit to $50,000, but the principle is unchanged.

The opinion also marks the limits of the rule. An acceleration clause is one that makes the entire balance due on a single default, so installments omitted from the first suit in that situation would be barred. Additionally, if the defendant has repudiated the entire contract, the plaintiff arguably must sue for all damages, “prospective as well as past,” or risk splitting his claim. (See Restatement (Second) of Judgments § 26 cmt. g.) Playfly raised that theory for the first time in supplemental briefing on appeal, contending that its June 30 letter was a repudiation. The court declined to affirm on that ground under the right-for-the-wrong-reason doctrine. Whether a repudiation is clear, absolute, and unequivocal is a question of fact, and the letter was not in the record. Playfly had answered the allegation about the letter only by saying that it “speaks for itself,” a response the court called “sphinxlike.” The court therefore left open the question of whether Virginia follows the Restatement’s repudiation rule.

The essential takeaway from the case is this: if you’re suing on an installment obligation, be sure to include every installment due on the day you file the suit. After that, if additional installments come due, you can choose between amending the complaint to include those installments, or you can pursue them later in a separate action. But before you do that, (1) determine whether the contract at issue contains an acceleration clause, and (2) analyze whether the defendant’s conduct could be characterized as a repudiation of the entire contract. If either of these questions can be answered in the affirmative, the safer course would be to sue for everything at once.

Contact Us
Virginia: (703) 722-0588
Washington, D.C.: (202) 449-8555
Contact Information